Question:

What's In ur Mind? Malik Mumtaz Qadri Did Right OR Wrong

by Guest1112  |  13 years ago

3 LIKES UnLike

What do you think Malik Mumtaz Qadri done a right thing by killing Salman Taseer Governer Punjab, Pakistan.

 Tags: Malik, mind, mumtaz, qadri, ur, Whats, wrong

   Report

29 ANSWERS

  1. Guest4659
    Malik Mumtaz performed an absolute wrong act of killing Salman Taseer, this was not the solution to it else he was not the person who said anything against our beloved Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) it was that Christian lady Asia bibi. This doesn't mean one shall kill her there should be a proper teaching place where such people should be retained and provided with the teachings of Islam so that such people shall understand what sin they did.

    This didn't happened for the first time and killing is not the solution for it as Islam means peace and do not allow anyone and anyone at all to decide who lives and who dies. We cannot stop such acts unless we do not understand the proper solution to it. Malik Mumtaz performed an absolute wrong act of killing Salman Taseer, this was not the solution to it else he was not the person who said anything against our beloved Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) it was that Christian lady Asia bibi. This doesn't mean one shall kill her there should be a proper teaching place where such people should be retained and provided with the teachings of Islam so that such people shall understand what sin they did. We shall educate people what Islam is all about who we are and why we are proud to be a muslim, the act carried out by Malik Mumtaz Qadri was wrong and I condemned it.

  2. Guest2485

     No one has the right to take Law in Hand. According to a speech of a Molvi anyone who say anything against Islam is liable to kill but i don't agree on it. Let Allah decide the fate of the person who said anything against Islam.


    Allah is the greater power and it has been written in Quran that if a person kills another person then he killed the whole humanity. If we start to take decisions on these deligate issues then we will corrupt the Islamic Law which out Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) taught us.

  3. Guest7034

     he did right .............hamare nabi ke khilaf kehne wala ka injam .........mout he honi chahe......

  4. Guest8514

    Qadri did a right job if governor had said "black law" to "blasphemy law".


     

  5. Guest3101

    I hope that Qadri suffers a fate worse than anyone has ever seen. Who the h**l gave him the right to take a life? I strongly condemn this act and hope that soon enough, one day another Kemal Ata Turk like figure comes to Pakistan and eliminates all these radical terrorists, who thing that they are Muslims, when in fact they are Kafirs! I hope this man and all those who support his mind set rot in h**l!

  6. Guest4118

    I hope that Qadri suffers a fate worse than anyone has ever seen. Who the h**l gave him the right to take a life? I strongly condemn this act and hope that soon enough, one day another Kemal Ata Turk like figure comes to Pakistan and eliminates all these radical terrorists, who thing that they are Muslims, when in fact they are Kafirs! I hope this man and all those who support his mind set rot in h**l!

  7. Guest7466

    Mumtaz Qadri doing a wrong act. He is Insulted Islam. Teaching of Islam did not aloow to do so. He act create a great hindress in preaching.


     

  8. Guest3292

    <p>Mumtaz Qadri doing a wrong act. He is Insulted Islam. Teaching of Islam did not aloow to do so. He act create a great hindress in preaching.</p> <p>&nbsp;</p>

  9. Guest1820

    <p>&lt;p&gt;Mumtaz Qadri doing a wrong act. He is Insulted Islam. Teaching of Islam did not aloow to do so. He act create a great hindress in preaching.&lt;/p&gt; &lt;p&gt;&amp;nbsp;&lt;/p&gt;</p>

  10. Guest1375

    he has done what government was supposed to do

  11. Guest2503

     The malik mumtaz qadri is right as becuse he is a trully mujahid-e-rasool (s.a.w.w.)


     

  12. Guest5204

    He has brought disgrace to islam. No body has right to kill anyone. These type of ignorant people have brougth Pakistan to this stage. they are bringing bad name to Islam. Islam is a religion of peace and forgiveness. I do not think there was any proof of Salman Taseer insulting the prophet (pbuh). Even if he had done it, the state should have punished him not mumtaz Qadri. Becasue of extremism Pakistan is has gone ages back.

  13. Guest4095

    Qadri did Right! as no one is allowed to support or break blasphemy law....Taseer you did it u got it! A one who stands for safety of blasphemy law is Mujahid OF Islam. GEO Mumtaz Qadri!

  14. Guest6568

    <p>Qadri did Right! as no one is allowed to support the breakers or break blasphemy law....Taseer you did it u got it! A one who stands for safety of blasphemy law is Mujahid OF Islam. GEO Mumtaz Qadri!</p>

  15. Guest5889

    Malik mumtaz qadri did very right and doing great job he is the Ghazi of new era and he proved that the Love of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) still in every muslims heart and soul it will never ends. He gave a nice way to all Ashiq-e-Rasool(SAWW) to get rid off from these kind of black sheeps. "Geo mialk mumtaz qadri"

  16. Guest7002

    Qadri is absolutely right.  Those who claim to be Muslims (so called) and support Taseer against Qadri need to either renew their religion or leave Islam.  The Prophet's (Peace Be Upon Him) respect is supreme to everything for all muslims.  Those who have forgotton this basic lesson in the name of moderanization or moderate Islam kindly stop distorting the best and everlasting religion of the universe.


    Qadri did what all true Muslims should have been after.  And this should be an eye-opener for those daring to repeat Taseer's blunder in future.  Muslim world is not short of followers to repeat the dose for them.


    Human crafted local laws can't be compared with Allah's laws.


    It is because of these liberal and ill minded muslims that sacrilage of Islam is surfacing every now and then by silencing voices like that of Qadri's and billions of his supporters; the sacrosanctity of Islam and the laws will only stay unaffected forever.

  17. Guest7659

    qadri ne khud toheen e risalat ki hai kisi ki jaan le kar. bohat acha hota agar wo rasul saw ki taleemat per amal karta. hamarey nabi saw to tamam jahanon k liye rehmat hain. aisey kareem nabi saw ki ummat itni zalim aur beyghairat k apne kiye per afsos. lanat hai aisey aalimon per, wakilon per, qatilon per. 


     

  18. Guest9672

    Qadri did absolutely right. Anyone uttering a single word against NABI KARIM SAWW will get the same reward as salman taseer has got. No Compromise on the prestige of  RASOOL ALLAH SAWW... Geo Malik Mumtaz Qadri...

  19. Guest2318

    I think, Qadri has done what his Eaman invoked. There was a comment that "I hope this man and all those who support his mind set rot in h**l!", then what will be one's opinion about two muslim killings  by Hazrat Umar Farooq, One, on the event when one MUSLIM deny to accept the decision of Hazoor (SAW) and other when some one (IMAM_E_MASJAD) started reciting the QURAN VERSE repeatedly in every Fajr Prayer in which Hazoor (SAW) were counseled in a lovely manner by Allah Almighty. Serat-e-Sahaba is rood map to Hidayah as said by Holy Prophet and my opinion is same as your opinion regarding Hazrat Umer decision.

  20. Guest9845

    GHAZI MUMTAZ HUSSAIN QADRI DID 1000% RIGHT  TO KILL THAT MALOON TASEER ......  ANY TRUE MUSLIM  IS EVER READY TO DO  WHAT GHAZI MUMTAZ  QADRI DID .....


      WHY NOT PRESISDENT ZARDARI AND PM GILANI STOP MALOON TASEER  FOR SAYING BAD WORDS AGAINST TH LAW OF NAMOOS E RISALAT ALHE SALAM  .......


    MALOON TASEER HAVE INSULT  ALL MUSLIM RESPECT  AND HE  THINK THAT PAKISTANI MUSLIM ARE COWARD OR POPET OF YAHOOD O NASARA  ......THEN  HE HAVE SEE  WHAT  HE WAS  TRYING TO DO ...... AND  THIS  IS THE LESSON  FOR  ALL OTHER  LEADERS , MINISTERS OR ANY OTHER  GAIR SABITH UN NASAB ......WHO EVER  SPEAK AGAINST  BAD  ON THIS LAW .....  HE OR SHE  HAVE  THE SAME RESULT....   INSHA ALLAH


    TELL EVERY GUSTAK E NABI  THAT  MUSLIM  IS EVER  READY TO DIE ON ISLAM  AND  RASOOL ALLAH ..... SO DONT EVER  TRY TO MESS  WITH  MUSLIM ......


    EVERY MUSLIM IMAAN  SAY THIS .........   EITHER  MUSLIM LIVE IN  THIS WORLD  OR  GUSTAK E RASOOL  ..... AND MUSLIM LOVE TO DIE


    INSHA ALLAH


    GHAZI MUMTAZ  HUSSAIN QADRI ....ZINDA BAAD ( LONG LIVE )

  21. Guest819

        He is The Best PERSON Of The MUSLIM NATION

  22. Guest7834

    It was not a right Act. Killing of a Person cannot be Justified. Specially if he is a follower Prpohet (PBUH) and his Kalma Goh. If someone thinks he has given some unjusitfied statment he should be Brought to Court and be Punished By the Islamic Court as Pakistan is not a jungle. The justice must prevail in this Country.

  23. Guest9351

    right act

  24. Guest9445

    How would we react if anyone insults our mother or father?  We forget every thing and start teaching that person a lesson.  The basics of Islam is that our Eemaan would be complete (Eemaane Kaamil) when Allah and His Rasool would be dearer to us than our mother and father and our own souls.  He was a Rehmatul Lil Aalameen.  Our mothers are also very loving to children but why we can not ignore if someone is abusing our mother or our father.  Because we feel that we are a part of them and it is our duty to silence that person from insulting them or doing any act which shows disrespect to our parents.  Our prophet Muhammad SAW loved us so much that at his death bed, he was worried about us(his ummat). 


    Should we ignore his insult, should we encourage people who are abusing him?????  It is a question that we must ask ourselves and not others?


     

  25. Guest1961

    malik mumtaz qadri doing wrong killing sulmaan tasser islaam is peace region  not permission  any body kill islam i brightmind region  He is Insulted Islam he is break the law  qadri ne khud toheen e risalat ki hai kisi ki jaan le kar. bohat acha hota agar wo rasul saw ki taleemat per amal karta. hamarey nabi saw to tamam jahanon k liye rehmat hain. aisey kareem nabi saw ki ummat itni zalim aur beyghairat k apne kiye per afsos. lanat hai aisey aalimon per, wakilon per, qatilon per.

  26. Guest9995

    Mughal shenshah Akbar K khud sakhta Deen -e Akbari k khilaf us zamane main Islam ko saheeh  tare se man nay or samajnay wali shkhsiyat hazrat mujadad alf-i- sani ( R A ) dat gae thy ,Aaj karoron musalman  hazrat Mujadad Alf-i-Sani (RA) k haleef hain jin main Mard-i- Haq ghazi Mumtaz Qadri b saf-i- Awal main shamil hy; muqtadar parties main se kisi ko b taufiq huee k malhoona aasia ki hemayat or Rehmatulil-halameen ki shan k khilaf bakwas ugalne wale jahannami ko cafer-i-kirdar tak puhnchne se agah kar sakay? 1 ayyash ko dad denay wale muafiqeen or mahooneen  ham musalmanoon ko Islami nuqtay nikak nikal k qanoon k pasdar ban rahe hain Kia Isamblion main yehi hlf uthaya tha k Lahnation k Dharhay main ja k un ki hamayat main bakwas bolen ga ,agar party sateh pe jahannami ki sarzanash ki jati tu yeh firhon kase  murdar hota. Islam k ley Pakistan Allah ne dia hy munhkalay k ley naheen dia.

  27. Guest3348

    MALIK MUMTAZ QADRI IS A GREAT PERSON.HE DID WORK TO SERVE THE NATION.NO BODY DID NOT CAN ABOUT OUR OPINION OF ISLAM.ALL THE MUSLIM WORLD HAPPY THIS BRAVENESS.

  28. Guest7301

    he s right


    he sacrifies his life for Islam

  29. Guest8187

    WOH SAB MADACHOD KANJIR KE NASAL HAAN HO MUMTAZ QADRI KE FAVOR KARTAY HAAN. WOH HARAM KE AULAD HAY. KISI KO KISI KE JAN LENAY KA HAQ NAHI. SALMAN TASEER NE PROPHET (PHUH) KE AGAINST KUCH NAHI BOLA. PAKISTAN PE AZAB MUMTAZ QADRI JAISAY LOOGOON KE AMAL KA NATEEJA HAY


    SHAHERYAR FROM KARACHI

Sign In or Sign Up now to answser this question!

Question Stats

Latest activity: 13 years, 4 month(s) ago.
This question has 29 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.